Would A Single Payer System Be Good For America?

Brian Klepper

ALP_H_BK_0010berwick_donOn Vox, the vivacious new topical news site, staffed in part by former writers at the Washington Post Wonk Blog, Sarah Kliff writes how Donald Berwick, MD, the recent former Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the Founder of the prestigious Institute for Healthcare Improvement, has concluded that a single payer health system would answer many of the US’ health care woes. Dr. Berwick is running for Governor of Massachusetts and this is an important plank of his platform. Of course, it is easy to show that single payer systems in other developed nations provide comparable or better quality care at about half the cost that we do in the US.

All else being equal, I might be inclined to agree with Dr. Berwick’s assessment. But the US is special in two ways that make a single payer system unlikely to produce anything but even higher health care costs than we already have.

First, it is very clear that the health care industry dominates our regulatory environment, so that nearlyevery law and rule is spun to the special rather than the common interest. In 2009, the year the ACA was formulated, health care organizations deployed 8 lobbyists for every member of Congress, and contributed an unprecedented $1.2 billion in campaign contributions in exchange for influence over the shape of the law. This is largely why, while it sets out the path to some important goals, the ACA is so flawed.

Understood in terms of its probable returns on a nearly $3 trillion current annual health care spend over, say, 25 years. the lobbying investment was a drop in a very large bucket. The negligible opportunity cost will generate returns for the industry for many years to come.

Second, every health industry sector – brokers, health plans, physicians, health systems, drug and device firms, health IT firms – has demonstrated and continues to demonstrate a willingness to employ institutionalized mechanisms of excess, most of them variants on over-treatment and stratospheric unit pricing, that allow them to extract more money than they are entitled to. This is why US health care costs double what it does in other developed nations.

It’s not that our people are sicker, but that we now accept distorted care and cost as normal. These practices unnecessarily expose patients to physical peril and cost purchasers double, displacing spending on other critical needs. Unfortunately, ACA does little to disrupt this waste.

Admittedly, employers and unions have so far failed to galvanize and mobilize their aggregated purchasing strength to demand greater health care value. But in a system in which the regulatory environment has been captured by health care, purchasers remain our most promising counterweight to the health care industry’s unrelenting cost growth.

Imagine what might transpire if employers and unions were removed from the equation, except for their contribution through taxes. The purchase of health care coverage would move from groups, who have latent but considerable power, to individuals, who have little to no power against monolithic health care organizations.

In the curious dynamic that has evolved, non-health care business and labor leaders could work collaboratively, serving as a counterweight to the health care industry’s excesses and holding their health care partners accountable. They could use their considerable purchasing leverage to reward organizations and professionals with good clinical and business practices and, frankly, punish those with bad ones.

But under single payer, we’d all be at the mercy of what occurs in the transactions between our Congressional Representatives and the health industry’s lobbyists. If the past is prologue, there would be little opposition, and the industry would have open field running.

Brian Klepper is a health care analyst and the new CEO of The National Business Coalition on Health.

About Brian Klepper

Brian Klepper is a health care analyst and the Chief Development Officer of WeCare TLC onsite clinics.
This entry was posted in Benefits, Brian Klepper, Conflicts of Interest, Health Care Cost, Medical Management, Policy/Law/Regulation, Politics and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Would A Single Payer System Be Good For America?

  1. The pivotal role of special interests in health-care (profit-centered care) is a serious problem that will need to be addressed at some point, regardless of what else we do. Nice discussion.

  2. Mike Masters says:

    Brian, these are excellent observations. The thought of a single payer system takes my breath away. All we have to do is simply look at the government run programs of Medicare, Medicaid, and Veterans Affairs, to see what we would be in store for. No thank you!!

  3. Health care and health care finances are really complicated — no way to change that. I think the goal should be to minimize the complexity for the patient and if a single payer system moves us in that direction it would be a good thing. If we need health care it should be as simple as showing a health care card and getting the care — done. No EOBs, no denials, no reams of paperwork and no having to select insurance every year. By the way — Medicaid and the VA are much more cost effective than standard indemnity based care.

  4. Lars Jensen says:

    I live in a small country (Denmark) with a single payer system. This public run system gives rather good value for out tax money, but that might be related to the fact that we have very little corruption of government, always rank high in the worldwide transparency statistics.
    Single payer system to my mind is vastly better than any alternative, but there might be a necessary order in which to get there, ie. getting corruption under a measure of control first.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s