Scary Predictions

Merrill Goozner

Posted 11/26/11 on Gooz News

Writing in next week’s New England Journal of Medicine, Harvard professor David Blumenthal, former head of Medicare’s health information technology division, forecasts the following scenario should the Republicans win the White House and both houses of Congress next year and repeal most of the Affordable Care Act:

By 2020, 20% of Americans may be uninsured, even as 20% of our gross domestic product is devoted to health care.

For the general public who are insured, that will mean no raises for the foreseeable future, since money once available to pay higher salaries will now have to go to pay the higher insurance premiums that will be necessary to cover the emergency room health care needs of the 65 million Americans who will be uninsured, up from 50 million today.

On the other hand, it’s an ideal scenario for the pass through agents and providers in the health care system. There will be no brakes on skyrocketing prices while those who pay the insurance tab are forced to pick up their exorbitant charges.

What will this mean for our political dynamics? We’ll no doubt see health care politics play out like tax politics. As the rich and upper middle class got more of total income yet paid a lower share of their income in taxes, those who were left holding the bag did whatever they could to reduce their own burdens. So they listened to the siren call of demagogues and turned on public employees and those less fortunate than themselves — those who “sponge” off the taxpayer. In the health care space, this reactionary response will take the form of rising demands to kick people off Medicaid, deny care to those who are uninsured, and eventually deny care to those who are Medicare and can’t afford the higher and higher co-pays . We’ll see real death panels in this country, not the fake ones of the Republican imagination. And they will operate behind closed doors without public oversight, administered by hospitals and physicians who will be forced to either deliver uncompensated care (charity) or deny people access to the system.

You’d think the day-to-day leaders of the health care system would be doing everything in their power to avoid such an ugly scenario. Yet I detect no groundswell of opposition from those quarters. It will be interesting to track the Big Campaign Contributions from Big Insurance, Big Pharma, Big Hospital and Big Doctors next year. So far, according to the Campaign for Responsive Politics, health care special interests have donated 55 percent of their Congressional campaign contributions to Republicans in 2012, and just 44 percent to Democrats. Four years ago, those percentages were reversed.

2 thoughts on “Scary Predictions

  1. Wow!

    You are not to rah rah for Obamacare now, are you?

    Just where do you make your assumptions that the repeal of Obamacare will cause the issues you presented?

    Costs are higher because demand is higher due to price fixing and collusion between the government and health insurers. The insurers decided to collude with the govt, but are only digging their own grave as Obamacare will put them out of business, which is the ultimate goal of Obamacare.

    Repeal and replace and get the collusion out of healthcare. Get real competition based on price and quality. It works in other parts of healthcare outside of the collusion partners, it will work throughout if given the opportunity.

    1. Yeah, right. Like dental care, perhaps?

      The only people with crowns, root canals, braces and high-end dental care are the ones with plenty of money to pay for it.
      What? Dental insurance, you say?
      Next time you go to a big box store or fast-food place ask the staff about their dental care. Or day-care workers or the majority of employees in the hospitality industry. Or better yet, those millions of unemployed people looking for work.

      Sorry. The medical care private sector is already there. It’s called concierge practices. And they do very nicely, thank you, but not by offering more competitive prices. “Real competition based on price and quality” means what Alan Grayson said was the GOP plan — Don’t get sick. And if you do get sick, hurry up and die.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s