Logical Bare Necessities


Originally published 2/7/11 on Organon

Andrew Koppelman at Balkinization calls Judge Vinson’s opinion a “bizarre collection of non sequiturs.” I’ve also noticed instances of the opposite: super-sequiturs—conclusions which logically follow from any premise whatsoever because they are necessarily true. Here’s one:

[T]he record seems to strongly indicate that Congress would not have passed the Act in its present form if it had not included the individual mandate.

(p. 66-67 of the opinion [pdf])(oomphasis added). I don’t know about the record, but the law of material equivalence strongly indicates that Vinson is right: if Congress had passed the ACAwithout the individual mandate, Congress would not have passed the ACA in its present form—with the individual mandate.

Continue reading “Logical Bare Necessities”